Yard Sale Mandoline

The Pumpkin Pie Project (with mystery ingredients)


Happy weekend before Thanksgiving, everyone! We’re so close to the official onset of the Christmas season, which always brings me a sigh of relief, because I get to mainstream my love of all things Winter/Christmas/Solstice/Holidays/Magical-Warm-Fuzzy. I have been listening to the music of the season at intervals for two or three weeks now, because it brings my heart a simple joy that I see no reason to deny. What could be wrong about allowing yourself true joy and warm fuzziness?

In that spirit, combined with one of efficiency, I decided last weekend to engage in a holiday-related project. Unsurprisingly, it was also food-related.

You see, our garden season, though less successful in some ways than in last year’s due to a very busy schedule and less TLC than normal, yielded us sooooo muuuuuuch squaaaaaash. Which is great! Organic, heirloom winter squash is sort of expensive because it weighs so much; it keeps in cold storage very well; it’s the perfect hearty vegetable for dinner on chilly Northwest evenings.

Just a portion of the bounty.

Just a portion of the bounty.

The point: my cellar runneth over with squash. AND it’s pumpkin pie season. AND I didn’t grow any pumpkins. So I thought to myself – there’s butternut squash curry and pumpkin curry. Pumpkin ravioli and other winter squash ravioli. Why can’t pumpkin pie spice coexist with another variety of winter squash?

Delightfully, it turns out pumpkin pie spice can! I made the exact same pumpkin pie recipe using red kuri squash (a hubbard variety), butternut squash, and, for fairness’ sake, a pie pumpkin from the produce stand down the street. I didn’t vary anything – except the crust on the actual pumpkin pie. I made the pies with the other squash(es?) first, using a new crust recipe that turned out kind of gross. It’s the filling what counts, though, and in both blind tastings and tastings with all the information present, the results were:


The pie above, made with red kuri squash, carried the flavor best. The spices melded together perfectly and it was delicious.


The pie above,made with butternut squash and a couple of seeds left on top to distinguish it, had the definitive pumpkin pie texture. Though I had to pour it runnily into the filling and was worried about its ability to set properly, the consistency was best of all three – creamy, light, and just yummy.


The pie above – the actual pumpkin pie – was “great.” In a blind tasting, though, a couple of people said “this is great, but definitely isn’t the pumpkin pie.” I found it a little fibrous, even though it was pureed just like the others.

There were no complaints about any of them, and lots of happy moaning. So there you have it! The conclusion: You can make a “pumpkin” pie out of the winter squash of your choosing, and even the discriminating of your household guests will flock to it and be satisfied.

Pumpkin Pie

With a mixer, blend to lumplessness:

2 C fresh winter squash
2 eggs
1/4 C light cream or whole milk
3/4 C rapadura (the most unrefined version of sugar, with all its mineral content and nutritional value intact)
1 T all-purpose flour or sprouted flour
1 t vanilla extract
1/4 t salt
At least 1 T pumpkin pie spice plus a shake of allspice powder (or an equivalent mix of cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger powders plus the allspice)

Pour into your favorite unbaked pie shell.

Bake in a 375-degree oven for 25 minutes covered, then 35-45 minutes uncovered. Savor with freshly whipped cream.

Happy Thanksgiving and official-beginning-of-Christmas to you all!




This entry was published on November 22, 2014 at 3:00 pm and is filed under Collection. Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post.

Have something to say?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: